Awards season · Directing & Cinematography

DGA Director Tells Adobe MAX: AI Tools Won't Fix Boring Ads

DGA director AJ Bleyer used his Adobe MAX session to argue that AI has made the impossible possible but not the uninteresting interesting, and to walk editors through classic ad campaigns.

Filed
Story625 words
Reading3 minutes
Day of year324 · Awards season
What Editors Can Learn from the Greatest Ad Agencies
What Editors Can Learn from the Greatest Ad AgenciesAMONWAT DUMKRUT / unsplash

Production notes

  • AJ Bleyer, a DGA director with campaigns for Ferrari, Riot Games and Red Bull, presented the session at Adobe MAX.
  • Case studies included DDB's "Think small," Avis's "We try harder," "Got Milk?" and the Martin Agency's 15-second GEICO ad.
  • Bleyer demonstrated Adobe Firefly work including a Miami sandwich shop ad built on a "horse" typo.
  • His stated rule: write the idea in one sentence before writing the prompt.

The hardest fact of AJ Bleyer's Adobe MAX session was not a tool demo. It was a verdict: generative AI has made the impossible possible, but it has not made the uninteresting interesting.

Bleyer, a DGA (Directors Guild of America) director with campaigns for Ferrari, Riot Games and Red Bull behind him, built his session around advertising's most durable work. His core claim is blunt. Better tools do not make better content. Better thinking does. He compared the current moment to inventing the printing press and using it for junk mail, and said most brands are wasting the best creative opportunity they have ever had.

The session opened on a familiar situation. The client wants the spot to say the brand is affordable, reliable and caring. Somewhere in the media bin sits a 40-second clip of the founder laughing at nothing. Nobody has told the editor yet that the clip might be the ad.

What does DDB teach the cutting room?

Bleyer's first case study was Bill Bernbach of DDB. For Volkswagen, in an American market in love with big cars, the agency wrote "Think small." For Avis, a rental company stuck at No. 2, DDB turned the weakness into the pitch: "We try harder."

The lesson, Bleyer argued, lives in the selects pass. The usable moment is rarely the one the brief asked for. It is the flub, the pause, the "wait, were we rolling?" He advised editors scrubbing a bin to ask what the footage admits that the brief will not. Goodby Silverstein & Partners applied the same logic to "Got Milk?", noticing that nobody thinks about milk until they run out, and building the spot around that moment rather than a nutrition fact.

Why cut for feeling, not features?

The second prompt was emotional. Crispin's IKEA spot made a room full of people feel bad for a lamp, then flipped the joke on them. Bleyer said it sold permission to let go of the old one. Wieden+Kennedy's Nike "Greatness" spot contains not one word about shoes. Its P&G Olympic spot, "Proud sponsor of moms," never asks the viewer to love a single product.

"When the information and the emotion are fighting over the same two seconds, give them to the emotion," Bleyer said. "Nobody has ever cried at a bullet list." An editor makes that call every few seconds, he noted, and each cut chooses what the audience feels next.

Can the format do the cutting?

The third prompt concerned the medium. The Martin Agency's 15-second GEICO ad wrapped up the sales pitch before the skip button appeared, then kept the joke going after it. Burger King used its 15 seconds to make Google devices read out what a Whopper is, so the ad kept talking after it ended. Google told an entire love story in a search box, with queries as the script and the interface as the stage.

Editors already work under run time, aspect ratio and the skip button. Bleyer's advice is to treat those constraints as material. A 15-second slot is not a smaller 30, he argued. It is a different joke with a deadline.

What is the rule for generative AI?

In Adobe Firefly, Bleyer built an ad for a Miami sandwich shop around a typo that turned "horse" into "house," played completely straight. A winding road on a poster in his living room became a Spotify spot built around "Take the long way home." His rule for the prompt box: do not ask how to make it look better. Ask what it could mean. Write the idea in one sentence before writing the prompt, and you are already ahead of most people generating wizard cats.

via filmtools.com (Original)

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Filmmaking News is the working trade daily for at Filmmaking News.

28 articles

Further readings

« Previous entryNext entry »