Awards season · Distribution & Festivals
'Endgame' Re-Release Outgrosses 'Supergirl': Superhero Fatigue Gets a Reality Check
A re-release of 'Avengers: Endgame' outgrossed DC's new 'Supergirl' worldwide, while 'Doomsday' presales turn profit two months before release. Fatigue, it seems, is selective.

Production notes
- The Endgame re-release earned over $100 million worldwide, topping Supergirl's under-$130-million total.
- Endgame reclaimed the all-time worldwide box office crown from Avatar, which had held it since a 2021 China re-release.
- Avengers: Doomsday presales are on pace to be profitable for Disney two months before its December release.
- As of November 18, Clayface had grossed less worldwide than Supergirl after weak presales.
- In 1959, over 30 regularly syndicated Western TV shows aired simultaneously.
The re-release of Avengers: Endgame has earned well over $100 million worldwide — more than DC's Supergirl has grossed this year at under $130 million. That single comparison does more damage to the "superhero fatigue" thesis than a year of box office commentary.
The encore release, timed ahead of Avengers: Doomsday this December, pushed Endgame back into the number-one spot on the all-time worldwide chart. The film and James Cameron's Avatar have traded the crown through re-releases since 2019; Avatar held it after a 2021 China reissue. Now the Marvel title sits on top again. Six years after release, on a re-run.
What does the Western comparison actually prove?
The genre's obituary writers lean on the Western precedent. The comparison has limits worth knowing before anyone repeats it in a greenlight meeting.
- In 1959 alone, more than 30 regularly syndicated Western television shows aired, none related to each other.
- Westerns died partly because culture turned cynical from roughly 1967 to 1975, and audiences stopped buying black-and-white moral codes.
- Re-examination of American history soured viewers further on the genre's version of the frontier.
Neither factor maps cleanly onto superheroes today. The oversaturation argument is real, but by volume the Western craze dwarfs anything the MCU produced. Westerns also collapsed for reasons specific to their moment. Today's problem looks smaller and more fixable.
Is the problem quality, not the genre?
Early-2020s MCU output diluted the brand across streaming, and even strong material struggled for attention. That flood has mostly receded. What remains is a straightforward split: audiences show up for characters they already love, and stay home for films they don't trust.
Presale tickets for Avengers: Doomsday are already shaping up to turn a profit for Disney two months before release. Viewers are not done with Captain America or Thor. Uneven recent quality has not stopped the nostalgia play from working.
When nostalgia is absent, quality gets no discount. The general reception of Supergirl was not positive — beyond the usual misogynistic noise online, audiences rejected the film's creative choices outright.
What is happening at DC?
Clayface fared worse still. Its presale ticketing grossly underperformed even Supergirl's, hampered by the R-rating and general doubt about the state of the DCU. As of November 18, it had made less money worldwide than Supergirl.
All of this lands after the firing of Safran and Gunn. The fate of the DCU is now an open question with no obvious answer.
The verdict
Superheroes are hardly dead. The market has simply been misjudging audience priorities: familiar characters still print money, untested ones do not, and the gap between the two now shows up in presale numbers months before a film opens.
Anyone arguing the genre mirrors the Western's collapse should note the difference. The Western died of cultural irrelevance. The superhero film's current problem is closer to a quality-control issue — cheaper to fix, and one Disney appears to be fixing already.
via No Film School (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Correspondent covering regulation, policy and their impact on Filmmaking News is the working trade daily for at Filmmaking News.
44 articles
Further readings
- North American Box Office Heads Back to $10B as China Slides to 2015 LevelsNovember 20, 2026
- Dune 3, Avengers: Doomsday Headline North America’s $10B 2026 OutlookNovember 20, 2026
- Horror Hits $2.49B Global Box Office, Blumhouse Atomic Owns Half of ItNovember 20, 2026
- 'Project Hail Mary' Books December Re-Release After $685M RunNovember 20, 2026
- Ebenezer Takes $19M Domestic, $42M Global in Depp's ReturnNovember 20, 2026