Awards season · Directing & Cinematography

Francis Lawrence's IMAX Return in 'Sunrise on the Reaping' Reopens an Old Argument

As 'Sunrise on the Reaping' revives the IMAX arena reveal from 'Catching Fire,' a new video analysis asks why Francis Lawrence's camera serves some Hunger Games books and betrays others.

Filed
Story724 words
Reading4 minutes
Day of year324 · Awards season
Why Francis Lawrence Nails One 'Hunger Games' Adaptation and Struggles on Others
Why Francis Lawrence Nails One 'Hunger Games' Adaptation and Struggles on OthersJoelFazhari / pixabay

Production notes

  • 'Sunrise on the Reaping' opens this week with an IMAX arena-arrival expansion mirroring 'Catching Fire', per DP Jo Willems in Entertainment Weekly
  • 'Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes' shot sequences in IMAX on the Alexa LF Mini — the franchise's first IMAX use since 'Catching Fire'
  • Gary Ross passed on directing 'Catching Fire' in 2012, citing a 'fixed, tight production schedule'
  • 'Mockingjay' was split into two films, keeping nearly every plot point but losing the book's first-person interior voice
  • 'The Hanging Tree' was repurposed as a rebellion montage in the film and later got a mainstream pop remix

'Sunrise on the Reaping' opens this week, and DP Jo Willems has already told Entertainment Weekly the tributes' arrival in the arena will widen to IMAX — mirroring 'Catching Fire.' The third time Lawrence's franchise has reached for that aspect-ratio trick. Whether it still means anything is the question fans are arguing before a single ticket gets scanned.

The occasion has sent viewers back through the whole series, and a new analysis from The Writer's Block makes a craft case worth stress-testing: the Hunger Games films succeed or fail depending on whether the director's camera agrees with the book's point of view. Sometimes it does. Sometimes the studio's wants bleed through.

What does the camera actually change?

Plenty, per the video's argument. Take 'Catching Fire' (2013). Suzanne Collins' second book is about the Capitol dazzling a starving population, and Francis Lawrence's taste for glossy spectacle fits that thesis like a glove. Katniss gets the makeover treatment, the Quarter Quell gets bigger, and the camera pulls back from Gary Ross's gritty handheld to show scope — Katniss dwarfed by the grandeur. Book and director wanted the same thing. That's the whole trick.

'Mockingjay' is where it breaks. The book is a war story told almost entirely inside Katniss' damaged head, in first-person present tense. Lionsgate split it into two parts, and the films keep nearly every plot point while losing almost all of her interior voice. The video notes the compensations: underground bunkers, no natural light, drab gray palette, an attempt to make her world feel closed and suffocating. An objective camera looks great on the Capitol. In the bunkers, it's a little boring — and a lead character sidelined by trauma doesn't generate much action.

Then there's 'The Hanging Tree.' In the book, Katniss sings it to push away arena memories, and the grim lyrics force her to rethink her choices. In the film, it kicks off a rebellion montage. It's a banger, granted. It's also not the story Collins wrote. And the mainstream pop remix that followed felt, frankly, tone-deaf. Studio and audience pressure — movies still need to earn their budgets back — likely drove those tonal misses. Give and take.

'Songbirds,' wide lenses and a camera that gives away the ending

'The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes' gets the sharpest critique. The Writer's Block flags that the camera sits below eye level with wide-angle lenses on nearly every character — an odd choice that skews the film. A low angle signals power, and Snow does become a tyrant. But the book needs the reverse: viewers should be drawn to young Coriolanus first, then learn not to trust him. Shoot up his nose from frame one and the ending has nowhere to go.

Lawrence's stated intent was different. On the wide lenses and the large-format Alexa LF Mini he and Willems used, he told IndieWire: "I like an audience to feel intimate with the actors, and when you use wide-angle lenses you maintain a sense of geography and scale as opposed to a long lens that compresses everything... The environment vanishes, and I feel that, subconsciously, audiences feel the distance."

Fair enough on intimacy. But the 10th Games in the book are deliberately shabby — falling ratings, low-tech broadcast, and Snow's arc is about making them worth watching at all. Lawrence shot several sequences in IMAX anyway, the first time since 'Catching Fire.' The video's counterfactual: a Ross version would have stayed inside Snow's calculating head and covered the games from a distance, through cheap monitors, as Collins wrote them.

The director who started it — and walked

Gary Ross deserves the last word. His shaky handheld in the 2012 original kept the audience in the arena with Katniss — scared, disoriented. Critics hated it at the time; new viewers now find it surprisingly grounded. Ross passed on 'Catching Fire,' blaming a "fixed, tight production schedule" that left no time to write and prep, per the Washington Times.

So what does all this change for 'Sunrise on the Reaping'? Nothing yet — another IMAX expansion, another Lawrence spectacle, and the same open question about whether the camera serves the book or the marketing. Check the frame rate of the argument when you buy your ticket.

via youtube.com (Original)

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in Filmmaking News is the working trade daily for at Filmmaking News.

39 articles

Further readings

« Previous entryNext entry »