Awards season · Post-Production & VFX

Nolan and del Toro Defend Human Craft in 'The Odyssey' VFX Panel

At a VES screening in LA, Nolan, del Toro and VFX supervisor Andrew Jackson broke down the Cyclops build and warned that AI threatens the craft fastest — and that artists must judge every tool's output.

Filed
Story629 words
Reading3 minutes
Day of year324 · Awards season
Christopher Nolan and Guillermo del Toro Break Down 'The Odyssey' VFX - IndieWire
Christopher Nolan and Guillermo del Toro Break Down 'The Odyssey' VFX - IndieWirepadrinan / pixabay

Production notes

  • Panel followed a Visual Effects Society screening at the IMAX auditorium of AMC's Universal Cinema in Los Angeles.
  • The Odyssey Cyclops mixed animatronic marionette puppetry, digital effects and Bill Irwin's performance.
  • Jackson, a former model maker, was the first person to read the Oppenheimer script.
  • All three speakers called for human oversight of AI in VFX.
  • Nolan described The Odyssey as his first fantasy film.

Christopher Nolan says visual effects artists must sit inside the main unit from prep onward, not arrive after the shoot to "add to the film." He made the remarks at a Visual Effects Society screening of "The Odyssey" held at the IMAX auditorium of AMC Theatres' Universal Cinema in Los Angeles, with Guillermo del Toro moderating.

The panel paired Nolan with production visual effects supervisor Andrew Jackson, his longtime collaborator, and broke down several standout sequences in the film — Nolan's first venture into fantasy, complete with towering monsters, swirling whirlpools and apparent magic.

What did the panel reveal about the Cyclops?

The early Cyclops encounter combined animatronic puppetry, digital effects and a performance by clowning veteran Bill Irwin. Nolan noted that Jackson, who started his career as a model maker, is always among his earliest collaborators — he was the first person to read the "Oppenheimer" script. Integrating the Cyclops's design elements required constant conversation from pre-production through the editing room.

Jackson said the schedule forced the team to cut build time. Nolan joked: "I like the word forced. It's good. I'm getting used to my crew members just vilifying me completely as we sit in these Q&As."

The constraint produced a better result, Jackson argued: "We basically just made a very, very simple marionette, which had still detailed solid components for the physical body, but just missed out on all the complicated joints and where the parts intersected." He added that its simplicity gave it movement with "a life of its own," which became compelling on screen.

Nolan's payoff line: "I knew that one day you'd be sitting here and Guillermo del Toro would say it was perfectly integrated, so it's all worth it."

How do Nolan and del Toro approach VFX integration?

Both directors insisted effects belong in physical production, not just post. "What's essential is having the visual effects team be part of the main unit through prep, through the shoot, everything — and not treating you guys as somebody that's going to come on afterwards and add to the film," Nolan said.

Del Toro agreed: "What I've found through the years is to treat the effects as a remedial thing that is separate from everything is a big mistake. The beauty of it and the respect for the crafts is to integrate them early enough so that they are part of a physical solution as well as the post-production solution."

What did they say about AI?

All three speakers stressed human oversight of the technology, arguing "The Odyssey" could not have been realized without cross-department conversation. Nolan defended compositors and animators specifically.

"In an age with artificial intelligence looming — with synthetic creativity around us, or whatever — it's actually very important to acknowledge the artistry that goes into the compositing process," Nolan said. His demand on compositors: use "their eye rather than their brain," avoiding simulated reality in favor of an impressionistic quality like that of matte painters working on glass paintings.

Del Toro went further on urgency: "The defense of the human touch and the defense of the craft is as urgent, if not more urgent, to VFX because it is the one that has gotten assailed the fastest by things like AI, which was not invented or demanded from any artist. It was demanded and created by people that were alien to that and appeal only to time and money mostly."

Nolan countered that the drivers are "time and money and also a misunderstanding of the process."

Jackson framed the practical case: "You're absolutely going to need artists to know even whether the new tools have delivered things that you want. You need people to be able to assess that."

via Google News · VFX & Virtual Production (Source)

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on Filmmaking News is the working trade daily for at Filmmaking News.

32 articles

Further readings

« Previous entryNext entry »